Dear Mr. Chairman and Representative Nadler,
I am writing to advise you of our opposition to H.R. 4639, the “Fourth Amendment Is Not For Sale Act,” and to urge the Committee on the Judiciary to reject it.
As introduced, the legislation would have a profoundly negative effect on public safety and on the ability of law enforcement to conduct investigations into violent crimes like murder, kidnapping, terrorism, and other serious threats. The bill would cut off access to vital investigative tools routinely used by law enforcement agencies every day—tools that generate leads into crucial and often complex cases. Investigators do this by selectively using third-party data, which is widely available for use for a variety of purposes that have nothing to do with public safety. If Congress acts to impose a probable cause standard for this type of information, routine investigations will become arduous and time consuming—delaying justice for victims. Investigations in which time is a factor—like kidnappings or human trafficking—will become impossible to solve, and lives could be lost.
The data accessed by law enforcement that this legislation would restrict is critical because it allows investigators to identify and pursue leads which in turn are used to gather evidence and establish probable cause for an arrest and prosecution. Without access to this type of data, investigators will not be able to “connect the dots”—to see patterns and establish links between the crime and the perpetrator. By prohibiting access to this commercially available data, Congress would not just be tying the hands of law enforcement, it would deny swift justice for victims.
On behalf of the more than 367,000 members of the Fraternal Order of Police, we urge the committee to reject H.R. 4639 and instead work with the Fraternal Order of Police to address genuine privacy concerns surrounding the availability of this information without removing this vital tool from our law enforcement agencies. Please do not hesitate to contact me or Executive Director Jim Pasco in our Washington, D.C. office if we can work together on this important issue.