Dear Mr. President,
I am writing on behalf of the members of the Fraternal Order of Police to respectfully request that you direct the Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service (FMCS) to restore its longstanding policy of providing case credit toward admission to the FMCS Arbitration Roster for graduates of the Becoming a Labor Arbitrator (BALA) course.
Law enforcement officers and the FOP lodges that represent them at the bargaining table rely heavily on the FMCS roster of arbitrators. Collective bargaining agreements between FOP lodges and their employers routinely designate FMCS panels for the resolution of grievances, disciplinary matters, and contract disputes. The quality, competence, and availability of the arbitrators on that roster directly affect the fairness and efficiency of these proceedings and, ultimately, the rights and working conditions of the men and women who protect our communities.
The National Academy of Arbitrators (NAA) assumed responsibility for the BALA course after FMCS discontinued the program. To date, the Academy has conducted two classes, with a third planned for later this year. When FMCS operated BALA, course graduates received credit for three written awards toward the five cases needed for admission to the roster and had the opportunity to shadow experienced NAA arbitrators as a substitute for required cases. That policy helped new arbitrators build practices, ensured FMCS maintained a skilled and qualified panel, strengthened the profession by developing the next generation of arbitrators, and gave the labor-management community—including public safety employers and FOP lodges—confidence in the capabilities of well-trained and mentored arbitrators.
We only recently learned that FMCS will no longer give case credit for BALA graduates, which will impede the ability of new, properly trained arbitrators to gain admission to the roster and will reduce the pipeline of qualified individuals available to handle the complex labor-relations matters that arise in law enforcement.
The NAA arbitrators designed the original BALA course in partnership with FMCS; only NAA members taught it; and FMCS required that only NAA members serve as mentors in the shadowing program. The FMCS and the NAA have a long history of collaboration on conferences, programs, and the Code of Professional Responsibility for Arbitrators of Labor-Management Disputes. That partnership has never raised ethical concerns and should not do so now. Both organizations are viewed by the labor-management community as maintaining the highest ethical standards.
We need your help. We ask that you direct FMCS to reconsider the change in policy and restore case credit for BALA graduates seeking admission to the FMCS roster to ensure that our members have access to skilled and qualified arbitrators whenever they are needed.
On behalf of the more than 382,000 members of the Fraternal Order of Police, I thank you for your continued support of our nation’s law enforcement officers and for your consideration of this request. If I can provide any further information about this issue and the importance of arbitrators to our rank-and-file officers, please do not hesitate to contact me or Executive Director Jim Pasco, in our Washington office.
Sincerely,
Patrick Yoes
National President

